THE SPRINGTIME OF OUR DISCONTENT

How five other institutions organize graduate and undergraduate programs in the arts and sciences


Return to Contents


The Springtime of our Discontent
Were last semester's debates on the future of the arts and sciences a turning point?

For practical and educational and deeply ideological reasons, I think the college has to remain the crown jewel for the university.
—Harvey Klehr, Andrew W. Mellon Professor of Politics and History

I felt as if the college had too hallowed a place in the university's collective imagination.
—Judith Miller, Associate Professor of History

Interim Emory College Dean Bobby Paul
On the relationship between the college and the graduate school

At a Crossroads: The future of graduate education at Emory
by Amy Benson Brown, from the September 2000

 


Brown University

The Dean of the College, the Dean of the Graduate School and Research, and the Dean of the Faculty all report to the Executive Vice President and Provost, who is responsible for all academic and budgetary functions of the college, the graduate school, and the medical school, including the academic functions of departments, interdisciplinary programs, academic centers, and institutes.

Columbia University
The Dean of the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences and the Dean of Columbia College report to the Vice President of the Arts and Sciences and Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences. That vice president, in turn, reports to the Provost and Dean of Faculties.

Duke University
Three academic deans—the Dean of the Humanities and Social Sciences, the Dean of the Natural Sciences, and the Dean of Trinity College—report to the Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences and Vice-Provost for Undergraduate Education, who oversees long-range planning for arts and sciences, senior faculty recruitment, faculty retention, space allocation, and fund-raising. The deans of the humanities and social sciences and of the natural sciences have budgetary supervision in their areas and assist the dean of the faculty in faculty personnel reviews. The graduate school dean, like the dean of the faculty, reports to the provost.

Harvard University

The Dean of the Graduate School of the Arts and Sciences, the Dean of Harvard College, the Dean of the School of Engineering and Applied Sciences, and the Dean of the Division of Continuing Education all report to the Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences, who reports to the president.

Stanford University

Five academic associate deans oversee the humanities, natural sciences, social sciences, undergraduate studies, and faculty affairs, and they report to the Dean of the School of Humanities and Sciences. There is no dean of graduate studies; the associate deans of the three disciplinary areas manage graduate education in their respective departments. An associate dean in the Office of the Dean of Research and Graduate Policy is responsible for university-wide graduate education policy.