Signing up for a philosophy course as a first-semester freshman
at Emory is gutsy, to say the least. But, Dennis Des Chene had 14
brave souls take on his “Philosophy of Space and Time”
freshman seminar course last fall.
Fortunately for the students, Des Chene understood what they were
facing. “I don’t expect them to get it right away,”
said the associate professor of philosophy. “One thing I’ve
learned after teaching philosophy for 15 years is that writing philosophy
is not an innate skill.”
The course was divided into two parts. The first part examined real
space and time as discussed by philosophers and what physicists
now believe to be true. Using texts such as The Philosophy of
Space and Time by Hans Reichenbach, students learned some basic
geometry of physical space and examined issues of measurement.
“Reichenbach points out that, at the expense of making your
physics more complicated, by inserting unknown forces you can accommodate
a lot of different geometries,” Des Chene said.
Through Robert Heinlein’s story, “All You Zombies,”
students were exposed to ideas of time by examining the paradoxes
of time travel. The main character of the story uses time travel
to become both his own father and his own mother.
“It’s interesting because it looks very paradoxical
at first, but then, after a while, if you think really hard, you
realize the only paradox is that the main character’s timeline
is a closed loop: The genetic information is coming from nowhere,”
Des Chene said. “In physical terms, moreover, even a little
violation of mass-energy conservation is a big deal.”
In the second half of the class, students read works of French philosophers
Gaston Bachelard and Henri Lefebvre to examine issues of socially
constructed and imagined space and time. Bachelard used poetry as
evidence for his ideas of space as it is imagined in dreams and
daydreams in The Poetics of Space. In particular, the class studied
his analysis of the categories of inside and outside, corners and
roundness, and the notion of a person’s “inner chamber.”
Through Lefebvre’s The Production of Space, students were
exposed to a Marxist account of the production of “social
space.” The class focused on the different ways in which social
spaces are constructed, including the factors that influence the
development of social spaces and how this has evolved over time.
“I didn’t want them to focus very much on the theoretical
underpinnings,” Des Chene said. “Lefebvre had a lot
of things to say about how city planning works and how social spaces
are created, especially in a society like ours where a lot of public
space is created through the market.”
Given the difficult nature of the texts, Des Chene attempted to
hook the students into the material by integrating their own experiences
into class assignments. For example, he asked students to describe
a public space and apply their new knowledge of Bachelard’s
and Lefebvre’s ideas to their descriptions. Students often
chose places they knew very well; one described a theater her family
was associated with, and another student wrote about a pool hall
he frequented.
“That was a good paper,” Des Chene said of the latter.
“Socially it’s a very interesting place. Often places
that are now pool rooms didn’t start off as pool rooms. When
buildings had been turned to a new purpose, I asked them to take
note of it and look at what happens.”
Des Chene’s attempt to make a challenging subject accessible
to the students worked for freshman Lauren Clepper.
“While we wrote demanding papers and read advanced texts,
Dr. Des Chene always seemed to keep in mind that we were only first-semester
freshmen and was willing to teach us the skills necessary for success,”
Clepper said. “I feel that this class helped me grow in my
thinking and my writing, and I will definitely take these skills
with me the rest of my life.”
|