Emory University
| Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee
| Calendar | Directory | Search |

IACUC Default Social and Environmental Enrichment Program for Research Animals

IACUC Default Social and Environmental Enrichment Program for Research Animals

Prologue
In order to enhance animal wellbeing, minimize animal stress, promote consistency, and comply with regulatory requirements, the IACUC commissioned a subcommittee to develop default enrichment standards, specifically defining housing conditions and socialization opportunities, for all species used in research at Emory University with the exception of nonhuman primates (addressed separately). Persons interested in the Emory Environmental Enrichment Policy for nonhuman primates are referred to: http://www.emory.edu/IACUC/pdfs/EEPolicyNHP.pdf.

The appointed Enrichment Subcommittee, consisting of Michael J. Huerkamp, DVM, DACLAM (Chair), Mollie Bloomsmith, M.S., PhD, David Knight, BS, Denyse Levesque, DVM, Deborah Mook, DVM, DACLAM and Jennifer K. Pullium, MVB, DACLAM, was charged to craft draft default science-based social and environmental enrichment programs for all research animals excluding nonhuman primates. The committee met on consecutive months from April through September 2005, reviewed 89 or more pertinent citations from the literature, and developed the specifics of the “Default Social and Environmental Enrichment Program” described below. This program was reviewed and approved by vote of a quorum of the full IACUC (Dr. Sam Speck, Chair) on November 16, 2005. For purposes of audit or historical interest, the subcommittee notes and proceedings have been archived by the IACUC office.


Introduction
The environment may influence the validity, reliability and replicability of experiments by introducing abnormal animals into studies, increasing variability within the population, and altering the number and type of individual animals between laboratories, respectively (Garner, 2005). In the context of the research animal, the environment consists of both physical attributes (e.g., lighting, temperature, cage design and complexity) as well as the nature of social interactions. In the proper care and use of research animals, the availability or suitability of enrichment must be considered in the provision of the environment and specifically with opportunities to exhibit species-typical behaviors and activity (Clark, et al, 1996).

When animals are unable to perform species typical behaviors and control their environment, unintended stress results and may become manifested as abnormal behaviors, both maladaptive and malfunctional (Garner, 2005). Abnormal behaviors in a population are similarly potentially confounding to science because they are usually expressed inconsistently across the spectrum of the group (Garner, 2005). Their expression varies by genetic background and developmental experience and may be difficult to mitigate with aging (Garner, 2005). As such, successful enrichments reduce or prevent the occurrence of malfunctional and maladaptive behaviors (Garner, 2005) through appropriately lifelong (e.g., from development onward) social and environmental enrichment (Baumans, 2005; Garner, 2005).

An important enrichment caveat is that social, environmental, dietary and other supplementations intended for improvement of animal well-being may alter important aspect’s of an animal’s physiology and development in ways not easily predictable based on what is already known (Benefiel, et al, 2005; Hutchinson, et al, 2005). Enrichment is a research variable that must be sensibly managed and must be biologically relevant. The effective delivery of enrichment minimizes or removes all non-research-related variables, while ensuring the scientific validity, repeatability and replicability of research (Garner, 2005; Weed and Raber, 2005). In essence, enrichment enables “good welfare” to equal “good science”.


Abbreviations and Definitions
Animal” – for purposes of the default enrichment program, “animal” is defined as to comprise all vertebrate species used in research at Emory University with the exception of nonhuman primates covered by a separate policy and program.

AWAR – Animal Welfare Act Regulations. Detailed regulations and standards for implementing the federal Animal Welfare Act of 1966 and subsequent revisions. Found in Title 9 of the Code of Federal Regulations (9CFR), Chapter 1, Subchapter A, Parts 1, 2 and 3.

Social Animals” – within the context of use at Emory University, the following species are defined as being social: dogs, cats, pigs, sheep, rabbits, guinea pigs, gerbils, certain vole species, pigeons, chickens, and songbirds. Although not necessarily social species, amphibians do have biological needs for certain environmental enrichments.


General Principles

  1. Social animals will be housed in compatible pairs or groups, rather than individually, provided such housing is not contraindicated by the protocol in question and does not pose undue risk to the animals in question (Clark, et al, 1996).
  2. The structural habitat will include objects that increase opportunities for the expression of species-typical postures and activities and enhance the animals’ well-being (Clark, et al, 1996).
  3. Particularly when social animals must be housed alone, other forms of enrichment must be provided to compensate for the absence of other animals unless scientifically contraindicated (Clark, et al, 1996).
  4. Exemptions from some or all of the requirements of the default enrichment program for scientific reasons, and if for all or part of the time maintained at the university, must be documented in the protocol and specifically approved by the IACUC (Institutional Animal Care and Use Guidebook. 2002. 2nd edition, ARENA/OLAW, p. 50).
  5. Qualified institutional veterinarians have the authority to exempt specific animals from inclusion in the enrichment program for reasons related to health, condition or well-being. The exemption and rationale must be documented in a medical record. Veterinarians doing so are obligated to review the status of the exemption at least every 30 days and renew it or void it accordingly (AWAR §3.8(d), §3.81(e)).
  6. This program should be revised with the addition of new species to the census or in the case where significant new information emerges or approaches to enrichment come to be the norm.


Default Enrichment Program Description by Species

Cats: Behaviorally compatible cats must be socially housed. Group enclosures should have sufficient resting places off the floor to accommodate every cat. Scratching posts and visual barriers should be provided. Multiple litter boxes, feed and water bowls should be distributed around the enclosure with at least one station for every two to three cats. If a cat is to be housed singly because of social incompatibility or is post-operative, it should be given a hiding place and opportunities for increased human interaction. Cats housed singly for scientific purposes should be within sight and sound of other cats and given toys, other manipulanda and opportunities for increased human interaction.

Chicks: Brooder chicks from 3 to approximately 14 days of age should be kept on contact bedding at a density of 30 to each brooder tray (1000 square inches (7.5 sf) with 42” of water trough and 21” of linear feeder) until the age of 1 week and then 15 to a tray until 2-4 weeks. Any chicks left after 4 weeks should be moved to an appropriate pen or cage with a roost, litter, dust bath and at least 0.5-1.0 square feet per bird.

Dogs: Canines should be socially housed in compatible pairs or small groups. Each home enclosure must have a platform, bench, step, bed, etc., to allow each dog an elevated and/or partially enclosed resting space. Likewise, each dog should have access to at least one toy when in their home enclosure. These toys should be rotated to maintain interest. If dogs cannot be compatibly housed continuously, intermittent social housing of 30 minutes per day, 5 days per week is allowable. Dogs housed individually must be within sight of other dogs. Those kept singly for more than 2 weeks should be given extra human interaction including petting, soothing speech, playing, and grooming for at least 10 minutes, 3 days per week.

(Gerbils: To be determined.)

Guinea Pigs: Guinea pigs are to be kept in social groups contained within pens and provided shelter space sufficient to contain all of the pen inhabitants simultaneously.

Mice: Mice are to be group-housed in breeding or compatible unisex groups on contact bedding with nesting material. Unfamiliar males, such as those acquired as adults from commercial breeders or breeding males given sexual rest, should be housed singly.

Pigeons: Pigeons should be housed in compatible social groups in flight cages with at least 2 square feet of floor space per bird, enriched with grains in the bedding, and with at least weekly opportunities to bathe.

Rabbits: Post-pubescent rabbits (>4 months of age) should be housed singly with the ability for visual, auditory and olfactory association with conspecifics. Rabbits housed singly must be provided a toy or other manipulanda on the outside/top of the cage on a regular basis to allow for exploratory behaviour. Nursing kits and rabbits < 4 months of age should be housed in groups, but accorded appropriate space per regulatory standards.

Rats: Rats should be socially housed unless scientific justification for not doing so is provided by the investigator. When single housing is required, enhanced environment enrichment meeting the needs of retreat space must be provided. Housing in high density ventilated caging systems with filter tops meets this need. Otherwise, for rats in open polycarbonate cages a PVC pipe section of appropriate diameter or shelter equivalent will suffice.

Sheep: Sheep should be socially housed in compatible pairs or small groups, unless exempted for experimental reasons by the IACUC, or for health or behavioral reasons by the attending veterinarian. If sheep must be individually housed, position them in such a way that they can see at least one conspecific, because visual isolation is stressful for sheep. Stressful research manipulations (e.g., venipuncture, drug application) should be accomplished within the presence of a familiar conspecific. Where there is likelihood of a single sheep remaining on census at a single cite, experimental plans must account for the timely use of the remnant. Sheep are particularly susceptible to isolation stress and those not obviously coping with social isolation will be subject to IACUC endpoints including veterinary interventions (e.g., tranquilization) or euthanasia. Sheep must be provided a diet high in roughage, to allow species typical feeding and rumination, and to reduce the likelihood of stereotyped behaviors.

Songbirds: Songbirds should be housed in socially compatible groups with perches, feeders, watering devices, and cuttlebone as appropriate for the species.

Swine: Behaviorally compatible pigs must be socially housed including, if necessary, combining pigs of compatible size and disposition to meet this need. Substrates should be provided to enable rooting behavior. Examples of such substrates include: plastic or bowling balls loose on the cage floor, baby pools or equivalent filled with balls and treats.. Swine should be provided manipulanda suspended from the pen side, such as hanging ropes, chains, tires or rubber tubes, for play and exploration.

Voles: Voles should be housed in social groups with males closely monitored for fighting minimally meeting the “Guide” requirements for hamsters. Nesting material in the form of hay, straw, paper products, or nestlets must be provided to fulfill burrowing needs. To maintain pheromonal cues and facilitate continued compatibility, part of the old nesting material should be transferred to the new cage at cage change.

Xenopus laevis: African clawed frogs must be housed in tanks with a population density not exceeding one per 2 liters tank water volume and as otherwise stipulated by facility SOP. With respect to the latter, water treatment, circulation and quality may stipulate that greater volumes be accorded per head. For animals housed with direct exposure to room light, refuges or retreats must be provided in the form of pipes, flower pots, or submerged plastic boxes unless the environment is already sufficiently dark.

REFERENCES

Cited References


General References


Cat References


Chick References


Dog References


Guinea Pig References


Pigeon References


Rabbit References


Rodent References


Sheep References


Songbird References


Swine References


Vole References

Xenopus laevis References


Emory University
| Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee
| Calendar | Directory | Search |
© 2005 Emory University
For suggestions, questions and more information: IACUC Site Administrator
Last Update: Monday, January 09, 2006