DISCOVER
Vol. 26 No. 12 | December 2005
THE
GREAT APE GUIDE TO HUMAN BEHAVIOR
Human
nature is a mix of selfish cruelty and cooperative kindness. As the aftermath
of hurricane Katrina so powerfully demonstrated, some people will open their
homes to strangers during a crisis, while others will run riot. Wherein lie
the roots of this paradox? According to primatologist Frans de Waal, we need
look no further than our close cousins, the chimpanzees and bonobos, to find
out.
Humans
share not only a common ancestor with chimpanzees and bonobos but common behaviors
too.
Bonobo
apes, humans' closest cousins, use sex to sidestep conflict.
Chimps
are socially calculating, and they can be decidedly nasty. Bonobos, on the
other hand, tend to be more egalitarian, and they often stave off conflict
with lots of sex. Yet neither species is entirely vicious or always conciliatory,
and each seems to experience love, empathy, and sharing - for good reason.
Like humans, both species are social animals, and in order to survive in an
unpredictable world, they must strike a balance between the two extremes.
De Waal makes his case primarily with engaging anecdotes drawn from a lifetime
of observing primates in captivity.
At
the Arnhem Zoo in the Netherlands, for example, he watched male chimpanzees
join forces for months to topple the highest-ranking male, females band together
to protect each other from male aggression, and the whole colony dole out
revenge when required. In one case, two young chimps lingered in the outdoor
enclosure one evening and delayed dinner for everyone else. The next morning,
the rest of the group cornered and beat them. That evening, the youngsters
were the first to come in. On the other hand, de Waal also saw impressive
signs of reconciliation and attachment among chimpanzees. The animals make
close friendships, hoot in celebration, and kiss each other in greeting.
Such behavior is even more exaggerated among the lightly built bonobos, each of which uses sex with every member of the groupÑmale and female both - to say hello or calm tensions. As with chimps, however, female bonobos have more social power, and males can be highly competitive.
Assuming
that social behavior has a genetic component, it is likely that humans have
inherited similar tendencies toward both aggression and mutual aid. Thus the
view of human nature as irredeemably cruel, warlike, and selfish - or as inherently
peace loving - is a mistake, argues de Waal. We are a species "capable
of unbelievable destruction of both its environment and its own kind, yet
at the same time possess[ing] wells of empathy and love deeper than ever seen
before."
--
Meredith F. Small